Tuesday, August 31, 2021

Review: How Lucky

How Lucky How Lucky by Will Leitch
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I love Leitch's writing style (ever since I first read his YA novel Catch and always appreciate the central Illinois references, character development, and swift plot that reads like YA.
Like other reviewers, I felt like this book had too much about SMA though--too many of the flashbacks were about the disease as a main point. I wanted to learn more about SMA as Daniel experienced life or as he remembers his past--but not as if I'm being schooled about the topic.

The plot really reminded me of the 2017 case of Yingying Zhang, a Chinese woman who was a student at the University of Illinois. She, too, was last seen stepping into a vehicle on surveillance camera, but she was brutally murdered by a former PhD student from Champaign. It's a horrific story (google it), and I'm glad Ai-Chin's fictional story turned out better.

I'm hoping for a YA novel next--I still think Catch is one of the best coming of age books I've read.

View all my reviews

Review: How Lucky

How Lucky How Lucky by Will Leitch
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I love Leitch's writing style (ever since I first read his YA novel Catch and always appreciate the central Illinois references, character development, and swift plot that reads like YA.
Like other reviewers, I felt like this book had too much about SMA though--too many of the flashbacks were about the disease as a main point. I wanted to learn more about SMA as Daniel experienced life or as he remembers his past--but not as if I'm being schooled about the topic.

The plot really reminded me of the 2017 case of Yingying Zhang, a Chinese woman who was a student at the University of Illinois. She, too, was last seen stepping into a vehicle on surveillance camera, but she was brutally murdered by a former PhD student from Champaign. It's a horrific story (google it), and I'm glad Ai-Chin's fictional story turned out better.

I'm hoping for a YA novel next--I still think Catch is one of the best coming of age books I've read.

View all my reviews

Review: How Lucky

How Lucky How Lucky by Will Leitch
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I love Leitch's writing style (ever since I first read his YA novel Catch and always appreciate the central Illinois references, character development, and swift plot that reads like YA.
Like other reviewers, I felt like this book had too much about SMA though--too many of the flashbacks were about the disease as a main point. I wanted to learn more about SMA as Daniel experienced life or as he remembers his past--but not as if I'm being schooled about the topic.

The plot really reminded me of the 2017 case of Yingying Zhang, a Chinese woman who was a student at the University of Illinois. She, too, was last seen stepping into a vehicle on surveillance camera, but she was brutally murdered by a former PhD student from Champaign. It's a horrific story (google it), and I'm glad Ai-Chin's fictional story turned out better.

I'm hoping for a YA novel next--I still think Catch is one of the best coming of age books I've read.

View all my reviews

Review: How Lucky

How Lucky How Lucky by Will Leitch
My rating: 4 of 5 stars



View all my reviews